top of page

Why do active managers struggle to replicate past success?

Writer: Robin PowellRobin Powell

Updated: Mar 5


Skyscrapers viewed from below against a blue sky with clouds, reflecting each other. Modern architecture, glass facades, and an airy atmosphere.


In evaluating fund performance, it's extremely hard to distinguish genuine, repeatable skill from random chance. Investors are constantly shown examples of funds whose managers appear to have demonstrated superior expertise. But we forget one very important thing: at any one time, there are so many funds to choose from that there will almost certainly be some active managers who appear to have exhibited skill.   


Most sports fans can think of a coach who succeeded with one team but then flopped with another. Managing an active investment fund is not dissimilar to managing a sports team. No matter how well-known you are, the fact that you've succeeded in the past is no guarantee you'll do so in future.


In his book Index Funds: The 12-Step Recovery Program for Active Investors, Mark Hebner uses the analogy of movie sequels. "Men in Black II, Ocean's Twelve and The Hangover, Part II," he writes. "All of these movies have one thing in common: they were abysmal sequels to blockbuster movies. We long to regenerate scenarios when everything comes together perfectly and the stars align, but that kind of success is rarely duplicated. "As hard as it is to (do) in the film world, it is even more difficult for these all-star money managers to duplicate their past success."




Here at TEBI, our preferred investment platform is InvestEngine. It’s cheap and easy to use, and you can be up and running within minutes.


What’s more, TEBI readers who start investing with InvestEngine receive a welcome bonus of up to £100. The minimum initial investment amount is £100. 


To claim your bonus, click on this link or use the promo code TEBI.


The Evidence-Based Investor MMXXIV. All rights reserved. Unauthorised use and/ or duplication of this material without express and written permission is strictly prohibited.

Regis Media Logo

The Evidence-Based Investor is produced by Regis Media, a specialist provider of content marketing for evidence-based advisers.
Contact Regis Media

  • LinkedIn
  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • TikTok

All content is for informational purposes only. We make no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability or validity of any information on this site and will not be liable for any errors or omissions or any damages arising from its display or use.

Full disclaimer.

© 2024 The Evidence-Based Investor. All rights reserved.

bottom of page